Settle or Fight? What the Changing Federal Enforcement Environment Means for Companies

  • Four federal contractors have agreed to pay more than $85 million over diversity programs since April, and changes made in 2025 may not cover earlier conduct.
  • The retreat in traditional enforcement is no safe harbor; Congress and state attorneys general are positioned to fill the gap.
  • Federal enforcement is not shrinking. It is shifting toward the administration's priorities, creating different areas of compliance and regulatory risk for companies.

Since April 2026, the Justice Department has secured more than $85 million from four major companies over their diversity programs, including a settlement with Lockheed Martin in early November. Those actions are likely to continue under Stephen Miller, who became White House chief of staff on November 9, 2026, after shaping many of the administration's immigration and enforcement policies. President Trump named him three days after voters gave Democrats control of both chambers of Congress.

For large organizations, the question is no longer whether one agency will call, but how many may act at roughly the same time and whether to settle or contest.


The Playbook: Multiple Levers, Simultaneous Action

The administration's approach pairs agencies and tools, and the recent experience of a global media and entertainment company provides a current example. In April 2026, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) ordered early reviews of eight broadcast station licenses, its first early review in more than 50 years, citing an investigation into the company's diversity policies. The company sued in August, calling the action retaliatory. In October 2026, the Justice Department opened an antitrust investigation involving five television networks, including several owned by the same company.

Universities have faced the same combination of funding freezes and civil rights investigations. Seven have settled, while a leading private research university chose to litigate instead. So far, the few organizations that have challenged these actions in court have generally seen favorable outcomes at the district court level. Appeals are pending, however, and government contractors facing False Claims Act exposure may confront a different set of considerations.


Four Enforcement Priorities

Exposure is greatest for government contractors, technology companies, and media and telecommunications companies, followed by employers that rely on large hourly workforces, manufacturers, and healthcare organizations.


1. Diversity Programs Enforced Through the False Claims Act

If you hold federal contracts, your past diversity programs are your exposure. 

The compliance certification is the hook. Under the Justice Department's Civil Rights Fraud Initiative, a multinational technology and consulting company paid $17 million in April 2026, a national professional services firm paid $21.5 million in August, and a federal contractor providing consulting and technology services paid $25 million in September. In early November, a major aerospace and defense contractor agreed to pay $29.5 million: $22 million under the False Claims Act and $7.5 million through the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. Two of the cases began as whistleblower actions. In the aerospace and defense matter, a former vice president will receive $4.4 million for bringing the claim. Several of the settlements reached conduct dating back to 2017, underscoring how long these matters can remain actionable. A March 2026 executive order targets contractor diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) practices directly. Whistleblower rewards suggest more cases could follow, and states are beginning to participate as well. In one settlement, Florida and Indiana recovered separately alongside the federal government.

2. Immigration and the Workforce

Your exposure runs through every subsidiary, contractor, and staffing partner. Immigration has been Mr. Miller's central focus. Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin's post-election message was direct: "Deportations will continue." Mr. Miller pushed Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) toward at least 3,000 arrests a day, and Congress provided roughly $170 billion for enforcement and border security in July 2025.

Large employers are already in view. A September 2025 raid at a Georgia battery manufacturing facility operated by a global automotive manufacturer detained 475 people. In February 2026, ICE filed a Form I-9 complaint involving the payroll provider for a national restaurant operator, covering 108 employees. A global staffing and workforce solutions provider settled its I-9 case in September 2026. The $100,000 H-1B visa fee is blocked by two federal courts and upheld by a third, with appeals pending in three circuits, creating continued uncertainty for employers that rely on foreign talent.

3. Deal Approvals as Leverage

  • Any deal that needs federal approval can become leverage. Companies pursuing transactions that require federal approval should anticipate that policy considerations may affect the review process. 
  • Conditions tied to diversity programs. FCC Chair Brendan Carr said in 2025 that he did not see "a path forward" for deals by companies maintaining "invidious" DEI programs. A major telecommunications company ended its programs before the FCC approved its $20 billion acquisition of a regional communications provider.
  • Clearance outside normal channels. The Justice Department cleared a global media company's roughly $110 billion acquisition of a leading media and entertainment company in June 2026 without major concessions, reportedly before staff attorneys seeking a broader review could weigh in.
  • States as a second review. Twelve states sued over the transaction, and the acquiring company agreed to a five-year consent decree with California before closing.

4. A Pullback That Is No Reason to Relax

A quiet federal regulator today is not a closed matter tomorrow. Public Citizen, an advocacy group, counts 212 corporate enforcement actions canceled since January 2025, across the Justice Department, the Securities and Exchange Commission, and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. That retreat is not a safe harbor. Statutes of limitations often outlast presidential administrations. That means conduct federal agencies decline to pursue today may still draw attention from future administrations, congressional investigators, or newly elected attorneys general in Texas, Georgia, Ohio, Iowa, and Kansas. Organizations also face a squeeze from both directions: steps taken now to satisfy the administration, such as ending programs to win a deal approval or settling quickly, may draw document requests from the new congressional majorities in January.

Why the Leadership Changes Matter

The leadership changes come as a new Congress prepares to take office and several senior Justice Department positions are turning over. Public reporting indicates the administration wants a more aggressive approach to advancing its policy priorities, while congressional control is shifting to Democrats. Together, those developments may increase pressure on agencies to rely on enforcement actions, funding conditions, regulatory approvals, and contracting decisions to pursue policy objectives.¹²

Once the new Congress takes office on January 3, 2027, enforcement priorities, funding conditions, and contract terms may become some of the administration's most important policy tools. The chief of staff plays a central role in coordinating how agencies carry out those priorities.

That same week, three Senate-confirmed Justice Department leaders departed, including the head of the Civil Rights Division, which co-leads the Civil Rights Fraud Initiative. Reported leadership changes also reached other parts of the Department. The departures added to questions about how enforcement priorities may evolve under the administration's newly aligned leadership team.

For companies, the key question is not the reason for any individual personnel change. It is how shifts in leadership could affect enforcement priorities, interagency coordination, and regulatory scrutiny in the months ahead.

Settle or Contest: Five Factors

The decision turns on the facts, but five factors recur:

  1. Certifications. Whether the organization signed the federal certification at issue, and when.
  2. Suspension and debarment. Whether a dispute could put federal contract eligibility at risk.
  3. Strength of the facts. What internal records and communications actually show.
  4. The whistleblower. Whether a whistleblower suit has been filed or is likely, and whether the government has joined it.
  5. Durability. Whether a settlement reached now could be revisited by the incoming congressional majorities or state attorneys general.

What to Watch

  • January 3, 2027: The new Congress convenes, and Democratic committee chairs take over.
  • January 2027: Newly elected attorneys general in Texas, Georgia, Ohio, Iowa, and Kansas begin taking office.
  • Civil Rights Division leadership: Who replaces Harmeet Dhillon, and whether the Senate confirms a successor before January 3.
  • First Circuit: The government's appeal of the ruling restoring Harvard's federal funding, argued in October 2026.
  • H-1B fee appeals: Two federal courts, including in a suit brought by 20 states, have blocked the $100,000 fee, and a third upheld it. Appeals are pending in the D.C., First, and Ninth Circuits, and the administration has extended the fee through September 2027.
  • More False Claims Act settlements: Four DEI settlements have come in seven months, and the second stayed under seal for 16 months, so others may already be pending.


What Organizations Should Do Now

  1. Revisit past programs, not just current ones. Review diversity programs and federal certifications across the False Claims Act limitations period, which can reach 10 years. Changes made in 2025 may not cover earlier conduct.
  2. Strengthen internal reporting. Make internal reporting channels trusted and easy to use, respond promptly, and protect reporters from retaliation, without limiting anyone's right to report to the government.
  3. Audit the workforce chain. Review Form I-9 compliance across subsidiaries, contractors, and staffing partners, and prepare a response plan for a worksite visit.
  4. Protect pending deals. Document every government and lobbyist contact, expect questions about diversity programs during review, and plan for state review even after federal clearance.
  5. Hold the line on compliance. Keep anti-corruption, securities, and consumer protection programs at full strength, and resist pressure to reduce compliance budgets now.
  6. Be ready to respond. Know where your email, chat, and financial records sit, and set the decision framework for settling or contesting before the first request arrives.

Organizations that act now will be better positioned to respond whether scrutiny comes from federal agencies, state attorneys general, congressional investigators, or multiple sources simultaneously.

How BDO Can Help

We help legal and compliance teams prepare and respond. Our services include:

  • Lookback reviews of diversity programs and federal contract certifications.
  • Investigations of whistleblower and internal complaints.
  • Forensic due diligence on pending transactions.
  • Compliance program assessments across anti-corruption, securities, and consumer protection.
  • Internal reviews of communications and correspondence, so you can know what your records and data say before federal or regulatory investigators do.
  • Data collection, electronic discovery, and document review for Justice Department, regulatory, and state attorney general requests.

Our professionals bring deep industry experience in government contracting, healthcare and life sciences, manufacturing and aerospace, technology and telecommunications, and media and entertainment. We use artificial intelligence in False Claims Act reviews, internal investigations, and responses to government requests to help reach reliable answers faster.

To schedule a readiness assessment, contact your BDO relationship team.